What Is Frozen Custard vs. Ice Cream?

What Is Frozen Custard vs. Ice Cream? The Definitive Guide

Frozen custard and ice cream, while both frozen desserts, differ significantly in their composition and texture. Frozen custard must contain at least 1.4% egg yolk solids, in addition to cream, milk, and sugar, resulting in a denser, smoother, and richer product compared to ice cream, which may or may not contain eggs.

The Historical Scoop: A Background

The history of frozen desserts is a long and winding one, with ice cream dating back centuries in various forms. However, frozen custard, as we know it today, is a relatively more recent invention. It gained prominence in the early 20th century, particularly at the 1904 World’s Fair in St. Louis. This event is widely credited with popularizing frozen custard, distinguishing it from the then-common ice cream through its richer egg content and unique freezing process. This event cemented frozen custard’s place in American dessert history.

Key Ingredients: The Recipe for Success

The core ingredients of both frozen custard and ice cream are milk, cream, and sugar. However, the presence of egg yolks is the defining difference. Here’s a breakdown:

• Ice Cream: Milk, cream, sugar, and optional flavorings. Stabilizers and emulsifiers are often added. Eggs are optional, and if present, are generally in lower quantities.
• Frozen Custard: Milk, cream, sugar, and a minimum of 1.4% egg yolk solids. Flavorings and stabilizers may be added, but are generally less necessary due to the emulsifying properties of the egg yolks.

The higher fat content (due to the cream and egg yolks) and the binding properties of the egg yolks contribute to frozen custard’s signature creamy texture.

The Freezing Process: Constant Motion Matters

The freezing process is just as critical as the ingredients. Both ice cream and frozen custard are churned while freezing to incorporate air and create a smooth texture. However, frozen custard is typically churned much slower, resulting in less air incorporation (lower overrun) and a denser final product.

• Ice Cream Freezing: Rapid churning incorporates more air, resulting in a lighter, fluffier texture (higher overrun).
• Frozen Custard Freezing: Slower churning incorporates less air, leading to a denser, richer texture (lower overrun). It’s often dispensed at a slightly higher temperature, enhancing the creamy mouthfeel.

Overrun: The Air Apparent

Overrun refers to the amount of air incorporated into the frozen dessert during churning. It’s expressed as a percentage increase in volume. Lower overrun means a denser product.

• Ice Cream: Typically has an overrun of 25% to 100% or more.
• Frozen Custard: Has a significantly lower overrun, usually between 20% and 30%.

This difference in overrun is a primary reason for the textural disparity between the two desserts.

Flavor Profiles: A World of Possibilities

While the base ingredients dictate the fundamental taste and texture, both ice cream and frozen custard lend themselves to a wide range of flavors. Classic flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry are popular in both, but the richness of frozen custard can amplify more complex flavor profiles.

Consider these examples:

• Ice Cream: Often features lighter, fruit-forward flavors or mix-ins that add texture, like cookie dough or brownies.
• Frozen Custard: Its richness pairs well with ingredients like caramel, nuts, chocolate sauces, and liquors. It also showcases classic vanilla and chocolate flavors with remarkable depth.

Nutritional Comparison: Indulgence Defined

Both frozen custard and ice cream are indulgent treats and should be consumed in moderation. However, due to its higher fat and egg content, frozen custard generally has more calories and cholesterol than ice cream.

Note: These are approximate values and can vary depending on the specific flavor and brand.

Where to Find It: The Quest for Custard

While ice cream is readily available in almost every grocery store and ice cream shop, finding authentic frozen custard may require a little more searching. Look for specialty ice cream parlors, custard stands, or regional chains that specialize in frozen custard. Websites dedicated to local eateries and online reviews can also be helpful.

The Importance of Freshness: A Custard Connoisseur’s Guide

Frozen custard is best enjoyed fresh. Many establishments make it in small batches throughout the day to ensure optimal texture and flavor. It tends to degrade in quality more quickly than ice cream when stored for extended periods due to its lower overrun and higher fat content. Always prioritize shops that make it fresh on site.

Common Misconceptions: Debunking the Myths

One common misconception is that frozen custard is simply “richer ice cream.” While it is indeed richer, the distinct ingredients and processing methods set it apart. Another myth is that all frozen custard contains eggs. While true frozen custard must contain egg yolks, some products marketed as such may be lower in egg content or use powdered egg yolks, impacting the final quality.

Making It At Home: The DIY Approach

While commercially produced frozen custard requires specialized equipment, it is possible to make a reasonable approximation at home using an ice cream maker. Recipes typically call for a custard base, cooked on the stovetop to pasteurize the eggs and thicken the mixture before churning in the ice cream maker. Be mindful of the egg yolk content and churn at a slow speed for best results.

Serving Suggestions: Elevate Your Dessert

Both ice cream and frozen custard can be enjoyed in a variety of ways. However, the denser texture of frozen custard makes it particularly well-suited for certain applications.

• Ice Cream: Ideal for milkshakes, sundaes, and as a complement to warm desserts like apple pie.
• Frozen Custard: Excellent on its own, in concrete mixers (blended with toppings), or as a topping for waffles or pancakes. Its rich flavor shines even without elaborate additions.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is the legal definition of frozen custard?

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) defines frozen custard as a frozen dessert that contains at least 1.4% egg yolk solids. This is a legal requirement for a product to be labeled as “frozen custard.”

Is frozen custard healthier than ice cream?

Generally, no. Due to its higher fat and egg content, frozen custard usually has more calories, fat, and cholesterol per serving than ice cream. Both are best enjoyed as occasional treats.

Can I make frozen custard without an ice cream maker?

While an ice cream maker is highly recommended for achieving the desired texture, some recipes suggest using a food processor. However, the results won’t be quite as smooth or dense as traditional frozen custard.

What does “overrun” mean in the context of frozen desserts?

Overrun refers to the amount of air incorporated into the frozen dessert during churning. It’s expressed as a percentage increase in volume. Lower overrun results in a denser product.

How does the temperature at which frozen custard is served affect its taste?

Frozen custard is often served at a slightly higher temperature (around 26-28°F) compared to ice cream. This slightly softer consistency enhances the creamy mouthfeel and allows the flavors to be more readily perceived.

Is all soft-serve ice cream technically frozen custard?

No. While both are served soft, soft-serve ice cream does not necessarily contain the required 1.4% egg yolk solids to qualify as frozen custard.

Why is frozen custard so popular in the Midwest, particularly in Milwaukee?

Milwaukee, Wisconsin, has a long and storied history with frozen custard, with several iconic custard stands that have been in operation for decades. This regional popularity stems from a combination of historical factors and a strong local appreciation for the quality and taste of authentic frozen custard.

What are some common stabilizers used in ice cream and frozen custard?

Common stabilizers include guar gum, locust bean gum, carrageenan, and cellulose gum. They help to prevent ice crystal formation and maintain a smooth texture. Stabilizers are generally used less in frozen custard due to the emulsifying properties of egg yolks.

Can vegans enjoy a frozen custard alternative?

Yes, there are vegan frozen custard alternatives made using ingredients like coconut milk, cashew cream, or other plant-based milk substitutes. These often use stabilizers and emulsifiers to mimic the texture of traditional frozen custard. However, these alternatives cannot legally be called ‘Frozen Custard’ because they don’t meet the standards set by the FDA.

What’s the difference between frozen custard and gelato?

Gelato, an Italian frozen dessert, is similar to ice cream but typically uses more milk and less cream, and generally contains no egg yolks. This results in a denser, more intensely flavored dessert than ice cream but usually less rich than frozen custard.

How long can homemade frozen custard be stored in the freezer?

Homemade frozen custard is best enjoyed within a week for optimal texture and flavor. After that, ice crystals may begin to form, affecting the quality. Ensure it is stored in an airtight container.

Are there different regional variations of frozen custard?

While the basic definition remains consistent, some regional variations exist in terms of specific flavors and toppings. For example, certain regions might be known for particular mix-ins or signature custard creations.

Ready to Level Up Your Cooking? Watch This Now!