How To Make Grilled Cheese Without Butter | Step By Step Guide

You’re about to make your favorite breakfast, a grilled cheese sandwich, and realize that you are out of butter. Now you’re at crossroads, but you don’t have to be. What you should do is find out how to make grilled cheese without butter.

To make grilled cheese without butter, preheat a skillet on low heat. Sprinkle oil into the skillet. Cut the cheese and place it on one side of the sliced bread. If you have other topping ingredients, you can add them as well. Then use the other slice of bread to cover the one with the fillings.

Most ingredients have alternatives, and butter has more than one. So if you ever run out while cooking, there is a way out, and this article will educate you on how to make grilled cheese without butter. 


What Can I Use Instead Of Butter For Grilled Cheese?

There are many butter substitutes for a grilled cheese sandwich. You are not just only limited to butter. Mayo, olive oil, and coconut oil are some substitutes for grilled cheese. If you make grilled cheese with butter substitutes, your sandwich will still be fine.

Here are some of the things you can use instead of butter.

1. Olive oil

You can use olive oil in place of butter for your cheese. Although olive oil does not have so much sweetness, it is rich and will give way to other ingredient tastes in the sandwich. Unlike butter, olive oil will not cause your bread to burn.

Enough of combing your fridge for butter. Pick your bottle of oil and sprinkle it into the non-stick frying. When the oil sizzles, place your bread with cheese and fillings until it becomes brown and crispy. 

2. Mayonnaise

Using mayonnaise for your grilled cheese will give you a thrilling sandwich experience. Mayonnaise is a combination of bread and egg, and using it for sandwiches gives an amazing result. Many people know about this mayo substitute for butter already. You can get on board. 

Using mayo is similar to using butter. Spread mayo on one side of the bread. Add the fillings to the bread and spread mayo on the other bread slice. The sides of the bread covered in mayo are the sides that will sit in the pan. 

3. Avocado Oil

Avocado oil is another butter substitute. No butter or mayo at home? Grab your bottle of avocado oil and pour it right into the pan and place your bread inside. When the down part of the bread has cooked for three to four minutes, you can flip it to the other side. Cook on medium heat until it is golden brown.

4. Aioli

Aioli is made from oil and garlic. You can’t go wrong with using aioli as a butter substitute for your grilled cheese. The creamy and flavorful sauce can be used for many things, like dip and flavor for food. Using the aioli for your grilled cheese will improve the taste of your grilled cheese.

The buttery sauce can be added before or after cooking the grilled cheese. Adding the aioli after cooking the grilled cheese preserves the aioli flavors and moistens the bread. 

5. Coconut Oil

If there is no butter in your fridge, you can use coconut oil for your grilled cheese. Coconut oil is still a good butter substitute. However, your grilled cheese is going to have a coconut flavor. Like olive oil, pour the oil into the pan and sit the bread once the oil sizzles. Toss the bread until both sides become golden brown.

6. Bacon Grease

Bacon grease can still cook your sliced bread with cheese to a grilled cheese. This option is great, particularly if you have bacon at home. How do you get the grease for your grilled cheese? Fry the bacon you have at home. Then use that same pan to fry your sandwich. Your taste bud will not remain the same after using the bacon grease. 

7. Egg White

You don’t need to go far for your grilled cheese. Do you have eggs at home? Bring them on. You can also use the egg white to fry your grilled cheese. This will be interesting because eggs are rich, and you can use the whole egg for your grilled cheese. If you are on a diet, egg whites will be great because it is low in calories. 

To use the egg white, break a little part of the egg and pour it into a bowl. Use a silicon brush to coat the bread. Fry in a skillet until it turns brown.

How To Make Grilled Cheese Without Butter: Step By Step

Making grilled cheese is simple and does not require much time. The good thing about homemade grilled cheese is that you can use ingredients brand of your choice and can include ingredients that suit you, especially if you are on a diet. Below are the ingredients you need to make grilled cheese.

  • Slices of bread.
  • Any cheese you love: you should consider the melting ability and stretchability of the cheese.
  • Butter substitute.
  • Any topping you want to add.

Here are the steps to make grilled cheese. 

Step 1: Prep Your Butter Substitute

Remember you want to grill cheese without butter, so getting your butter substitute ready should be the first step. If you are using bacon grease, first fry your bacon and get the grease ready. If you are using eggs, bring out the eggs and break them into a bowl.

Step 2: Preheat The Skillet Or Non-Stick Frying Pan

Once you have prepared your butter replacement, heat your skillet or non-stick fry pan on low heat. 

Step 3: Add The Butter Substitute To The Pan

Go ahead and add the butter substitute to the pan, especially if you are using any oil as a substitute. 

Step 4: Coat One Side Of The Bread

For a butter substitute like egg white or mayonnaise, spread it on one side of the bread and place it in the pan.

Step 5: Add Cheese And Other Toppings

While the bread in the pan is getting hot, add cheese and toppings of your choice to the bread in the pan. Coat the other slice of bread and place the uncovered part on the bread in the pan. 

Step 6: Toss The Sandwich Until Done

Cover the skillet or non-stick frypan so that the heat cannot escape and the cheese can melt faster. After about three to four minutes, flip the other side of the sandwich until it turns golden brown. If you want, you can leave it to cook until it is crispy. 

What Happens If You Don’t Put Butter On Grilled Cheese?

What will happen if you don’t use butter on grilled cheese is that the outcome of your grilled cheese will be dry. The cheese may be unevenly distributed. If you don’t want to use butter for your grilled cheese, you can use butter substitutes like olive oil, coconut oil, etc. 


You can enjoy grilled cheese without butter because there are many butter alternatives. You just need to learn how to use each substitute, and this article has done justice to that. Enjoy your grilled cheese. 

About The Author

Hi There, I'm Lisa Anderson. I'm a 30-year-old with a passion for cooking, art, and dogs (not always in that order). With a background in both cooking and writing, ShiftyChevre is a collection of my experiences with food, recipes, lifestyle, and other kitchen-related topics.

Leave a Comment